Haven’t written in a while here, so just to open the floodgates, here’s a quick review of two shows. One’s brand new, one’s half a season old; one’s a comedy, one’s a drama. But they’re both similar, in that they aspire to be nothing more than mash-ups of previous series, in terms of style and plot. (At least, I was going to review two shows – but I’m bailing early and just doing one.)
The Event
(NBC; returns March __)
The commercials gave the impression that this was a clever marriage of “24″ and “Lost”. After watching the first 4 episodes, I’ve realized: it’s a marriage of the worst elements of “24″ and “Lost”.
“24″ had a relentless beat, and, in its best moments, was an adrenaline-filled roller-coaster. It could get away with amazing action sequences that defied logic, and consequences, since the entire TV season took place during one day. “The Event” has bad guys killing a half-dozen agents in an FBI office, but (at least by episode 5), there are absolutely no repercussions of that act. A plane load of people go missing, but apparently there’s no outcry from the passengers’ relatives and friends when they don’t arrive at their destination. (Okay, they eventually touched on that in a later episode.) It’s hard to willingly suspend our disbelief for the sci-fi elements of this series when it can’t even properly react to ‘real-world’ events like shootings and kidnappings.
“Lost” started in a fairly grounded reality, if a spectacular one: a plane has crashed on an island. Some have survived, others haven’t. The producers wisely only introduced the mythological elements after establishing a reality for the characters. “The Event”, perhaps sensing that it won’t ever have the luxury of six seasons to build its mythology, is throwing everything it has against the wall: there are aliens, disappearing airplanes, and mysterious diseases that can be fixed with simple injections. It’s Sci-Fi that looks more like CSI.
Another element borrowed from “Lost” is the jumps in the chronological narrative. Just when something interesting is about to happen, it seems, there’s a jump to another time frame for a mini flash back. I swear I even heard a similar rumble that accompanied the Flash forwards and backwards in “Lost”. While it worked in “Lost”, here it seems like a storytelling crutch.
All told, “The Event” is just grabbing some familiar elements of both “24″ and “Lost”, but without the dramatic rigeur both those shows were (usually) able to offer. As a result, the show feels like a repeat the first time you see it. (I can’t picture anyone willingly watching this a second time.)
The re-tread feel isn’t helped by the casting, which features well-known faces coming close to reprising their previous roles. Blair Underwood, from “L.A. Law”, is pitted against Laura Innes, formerly of “E.R.” Often, when the two are on-screen, I can’t help but feel I’m watching a special cross-over episode of the two shows, and Dr. Kerri Weaver is calmly discussing a case with her lawyer Jonathan Rollins. Or maybe it’s just me that thinks this is NBC’s way to desperately remind people, “Hey! We used to own Thursdays at 10 PM!”
Other great actors are on-board, like Bill Smitrovich, Zeljko Ivanek, and Hal Holbrook. (Hal Holbrook!!) Unfortunately, not one of them has a real character to play – each only serves to advance the plot, and deliver expository dialogue between action sequences. Their roles are so similiar to what they’ve done before, in “24″, “Lost”, or “The West Wing”, that it seems the producers of “The Event” are just cutting and pasting situations from previous series, and bringing the same actors along for the ride. Or maybe hiring actors to recreate their similar roles is easier than hunting through a bunch of new headshots.
And speaking of characters – it’s hard to feel any affinity for any of the characters here. By the third episode, I didn’t really care if the main character was reunited with his missing finance or not.
“The Event”, like “”No Ordinary Family” and other sci-fi series, asks us to suspend our disbelief. Ironically, that’s sometimes harder to do when the setting is based on reality rather than a obvious ‘out-there’ sci-fi scenario. Yes, I’ll believe a starship the size of a small city can travel faster than light – but I can’t believe dozens of cops and FBI agents can be murdered and no one raises the alarm. (Nor can I believe the President would jet around the country to stare stoically at a secret plane crash site with 200 dead bodies.) That tightrope suspension of disbelief for the sci-fi elements of a series is undermined when it can’t get “real-world” things right. (As an aside – that’s why I gave up on “No Ordinary Family” after three episodes. Drama is conflict, I know – but unmotivated conflict equals melodrama. On “Family”, the newly-genius son was still being accused of cheating in school long afterward he got his “powers”. It ain’t hard to tell the difference between a kid cheating, or a kid who really knows how to do advanced math.)
So, why am I still watching? Well, I was going to add this show, plus “Chase” and “No Ordinary Family” to my viewing this year. I’ve explained above why I’ve ditched “Family”, and “Chase” lost me in the first episode during a ridiculous shoot-out. So, since I’m not watching those two, I thought I’d at least watch “Event” limp to the finish line. And somehow, the advanced notice of its cancellation also helped me watch it: somehow, it seems easier to justify my time with “The Event” because I know it’s ending. Had it been renewed, I would have ditched this a long time ago. And now, I wish I had.
Recent Comments